East Bay High School Football: Overtime Thriller Recap

San Leandro walked out of James Logan's stadium in Union City on Friday, October 30, 2026, with a 40-28 overtime win. The No. 17 Spartans, now 8-1, needed that extra period to claim at least a share of the West Alameda County Conference Foothill Division title. For east bay high school football fans, it was the kind of close, high-stakes conference game that defines a season.

[Lead image: Illustration of a high school football stadium at dusk, two teams lined up at the line of scrimmage. Credit: AI-generated illustration. Not a game photograph.]

The final and what it settled

The Mercury News Week 10 scoreboard, published November 1, 2026, lists the result plainly: No. 17 San Leandro (8-1) beat James Logan 40-28 in overtime. The game took place at James Logan High School in Union City on Friday, October 30. The Bay Area News Group assigned it one of their headline Week 10 slots, alongside Serra's rout of Archbishop Riordan and Saratoga's win over Homestead.

Key details confirmed by the MaxPreps game page:

• Final score: San Leandro 40, James Logan 28 (OT)
• Date: Friday, October 30, 2026
• Site: James Logan High School, Union City, Calif.
• San Leandro record after the win: 8-1
• Stakes: WAC Foothill Division crown (at least a share)

The division title was the real story here. According to Darren Sabedra's Bay Area News Group roundup, San Leandro's overtime triumph at James Logan settled the Foothill Division race in the Spartans' favor. The Mercury News tagged it an "overtime thriller" in their Week 10 coverage, a label that undersells how much was riding on the final possession.

What does California overtime actually require?

California Interscholastic Federation rules set a specific structure for extra periods that differs from the college format most casual fans follow on a Saturday night.

The framework works like this:

• First overtime: Each team receives one possession starting at the opponent's 25-yard line
• Second overtime: A two-point conversion must be attempted by the team that scores a touchdown
• The game ends the moment one team out-scores the other in a single overtime period

That second-overtime conversion rule is the part that changes how coaches call the final plays. You are not kicking a field goal to extend. You are going for two, and the margin between winning and another overtime is a single conversion attempt. For a 40-28 final, that means the game was likely tied or within a single score after regulation, and the extra period produced enough points to separate the teams by 12.

The two-point conversion that anchored the night

Bay Area News Group photographer Shae Hammond captured San Leandro's Deyar Crayton (14) and Ellis Lockett (3) celebrating a two-point conversion against James Logan during the game. The image, published November 1, 2026, shows the kind of physical, shoulder-to-shoulder celebration that follows a high-pressure conversion in east bay high school football. You can tell from the body language that the play mattered. It was not a routine extra.

Individual statistics for this contest were not posted on the MaxPreps game page. What the available sources confirm is the 40-28 final, the overtime format, and the division-title stakes. The full box score, quarter-by-quarter breakdown, and player-by-player numbers remain unavailable at this time. I am not filling those gaps with guesses.

Where this sits in the broader season

MaxPreps lists San Leandro at a CA Rank of 239 for the 2026-27 season, with a 3-0 league record placing them first in their division. The 8-1 overall mark from the Mercury News scoreboard aligns with a team that entered Week 10 as a top-20 program in the Bay Area. A 40-28 win over a conference opponent in overtime is exactly the kind of result that cements a division lead.

What the sources confirm about this specific game:

• San Leandro entered as the No. 17 ranked team in the Bay Area
• The game required an overtime period to decide
• The win secured at least a share of the Foothill Division crown
• Bay Area News Group published photo, scoreboard, and roundup coverage

For James Logan, the loss keeps them in Foothill Division contention, though the exact post-game record is not specified in the sources I reviewed. The Mercury News coverage frames the contest as a competitive conference matchup that required an extra period to separate. That tells you the margin was tight enough to matter through four quarters and into the extra frame.

East bay high school football in the East Bay produces these games every October: two programs separated by a few points, a division title on the line, and an overtime structure that punishes hesitation. The 40-28 final looks decisive on paper. The fact that it required overtime says otherwise.

Tri-City Athlete covers east bay high school football, basketball, and track across the East Bay. Hungry after the game? Order from Round Table Pizza and get your team's game-day fuel on the house.

[Round Table Pizza offer image linking to ordering page]